1. Palmer's Beverage on Indianola and High
2. Dairy Mart on Fifth and Highland- This place looks like it would only carry 40s. But it has one of the best selections of pounders in the city.
3. Blacklick Wine and Spirits: I always find something in this place that I've never seen before. This is probably my hands down, most favorite beer store in the city. And they have a pretty good selection of liquor as well!
4. Whole Foods, Sawmill and 161: You can find almost any locally brewed beer here. They even carry Rockmill Brewery from Lancaster, which I have never seen anywhere else.
5. Giant Eagles tend to be good. Some are better than others. Market District in Upper Arlington is the best. The Giant Eagle in New Albany is pretty good as well. The Giant Eagle on Neil Ave near Arena District is the worst because they don't have space to have much of a selection.
6. The Kroger Marketplace on Northwest and Chambers carries the seasonal Rogue pounders, and some of the other big micro seasonals.
7. Gentiles is pretty good, but I'm not usually there for the beer, but the brewing supplies.
8. Grapes of Mirth at the North Market: This guy mainly specializes in wine, but you can find some neat surprises here. He usually tries to get Dogfish Head's limited release stuff.
1. Barley's Tap House: This is probably my favorite one mostly because of the firkin handle and the cask conditioned tap.
2. Elevator: Good food, and their beer is better every year. They are on the up.
3. Gordon Biersh: They're beer is good. Their food is decent. Their prices are preposterous.
1. Rockmill: I've never been here, or had any of their stuff, but I've heard good things.
2. Neill House: I caught these guys at the last microbrew festival at the North Market. I tried the Cranberry Cider which was very impressive. I wasn't able to try anything else because it all ran out.
1. Bodega: This place has about 30-40 microbrews on tap at all times and switch their selection with the seasons. If you like beer, this is a must.
2. Lounge 62: This has been mentioned a couple of times and I agree that it is a pretty good bar. They also have a large selection, though most of the beers are either large breweries or the flagships of the microbrews. Every once in awhile they will put something different on tap. Look out for those.
3. RBar: Come on....they don't have anything but domestics/canadians but GO JACKETS!
I hit the Andersen's up a lot. As far as bars go, I like CBC a lot as well as Byrne's Pub. There is another place, I don't know if it is in Grandview, but I think it is called the Thirsty Ear. The have a pretty extensive draft selection. I need to get into BJ's though in Polaris.
As far as carry outs go, I like Gentiles and (believe it or not) Giant Eagle.
x2, Gentiles is great, so is the Kenny Road Carryout (where Kenny splits, godown the left, take kenny to the right). I refer to it as Beer Paradise...HUGE selection of microbrews and seasonals, and the guys that work there are all extremely knowledgeable.
As far as beers on tap, there's a place on High Street called Bodega that has one of the largerst selections I have ever seen.
I know it's not really Columbus, but weasleboy in Zanesville is interesting. A brewpub that recently got a bronze for their imperial stout at the great American beer festival. They're super friendly and offer a stout float. No food last I was there.