Three Floyd's is overrated. I've had their Alpha King, Gumball, and Robert the Bruce. I found each to be unbalanced and bland. I like some of Upland's stuff. I've been most impressed with Barley Island Brewing in Noblesville. Their Dirty Helen is a great brown ale. Mad Anthony is also pretty decent stuff.
Here is Lafayette, the LBC is horrible beer, but they do make good bison burgers. All their beer tastes watered down and flavorless. Sometimes the Common is decent, but I don't waste my money there.
People's IPA is some excellent beer. One of the best IPA's I've ever had. Unfortunately, all their other stuff is similar tasting and 1-dimensional.
I'm such a hard man to please.