Need Long Island, NY Best Seafood Recommendations

[PierceNY]

I'm looking for recommendations for the BEST seafood restaurant in Suffolk County, Long Island. I'm planning to take my wife out for a congratulatory dinner on our new baby girl. Please help! and thanks

[MAMMOTH]

Congrats, however this might not be the best place to ask.
Try the NY thread under states.

[paddyboy2u]

Originally Posted by PierceNY

I'm looking for recommendations for the BEST seafood restaurant in Suffolk County, Long Island. I'm planning to take my wife out for a congratulatory dinner on our new baby girl. Please help! and thanks

When I was on Long Island I ate here a few times. If I remember correctly the have all you can eat shrimp on Wed. and all you can eat crab legs on Thursdays. Not bad food and a pretty good price. And Coram isnt really that far from Sayville.
Good Luck and congratulations on the new baby.


Popei's Clam Bar
(631) 696-4029

451 Middle Country Rd, Coram, NY

[Angelveto]

Sea Basin in Rocky Point is supposed to be simply amazing, as its parking lot attests too.

642 Route 25A Rocky Point NY, 11778

[PierceNY]

I'll try both restaurants and let you know how they are. Thanks!

[PierceNY]

Originally Posted by MAMMOTH

Congrats, however this might not be the best place to ask.
Try the NY thread under states.

Mammoth; I thought I was posting in the right spot... can you please point me in the right direction?

[khugs21]

Cladios in greenport is good. More of a summer/spring place do to it being mainly outside.

[khugs21]

also the catch in PortJeff.

[Izzy]

My wife worked at Nicky's in Bayshore. They have 2 restaurants. Nicky's Clam Bar and Nicky's on the Bay. I liked Nicky's on the Bay but it is mostly outdoor seating and is better during the summer months. I think they might be closed now. But Nicky's Clam Bar is open year round.

[iworkatinitech]

It kind of depends where you want to be going, Suffolk is quite large. Obviously Montauk has some of the best spots (Gurneys, Gossmans, Lobster Deck [seasonal], etc.), I've always heard good things about Popei's but I've never been myself.

If you want to go to the North Fork, Claudio's (in Greenport) is pretty much THE place, but as was said above it's really more of a summer place.

In Huntington the place would probably be Honu (atmosphere) or Kotobuki (for sushi).

Just a sampling but it depends where you want to go.