Originally Posted by brian92
Mitchell's is still my favorite. Their Grasshopper Pie ice cream is awesome.
Oh my god it's like heaven in my mouth.
I have tried Mitchell's and Humphrey Slocombe and sampled Bi-Rite. I have to say Mitchell's takes them all. They have more traditional flavors, but real quality. They also have great fruit flavors and seasonals (cantelope and egg nog are some of my favorites). Humphrey is all exotic flavors, I don't think they have a single traditional flavor ice cream. They are hit or miss with me, but it's fun to try the weird ones. Bi-Rite I've only had a free sample on the street, it was good but not astonishing. I guess I should give it another try.